{
  "result_set_id": "CWSE-EVALUATION-RESULTS",
  "version": "0.1.0",
  "classification": "illustrative_value",
  "normative": false,
  "engineering_approval": false,
  "scope": "Coordination outcomes only. A valid result means valid within the stated deterministic coordination scope, not approved for design, procurement, fabrication, or installation.",
  "evaluation_results": [
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "valid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-CAST-IN-CHANNEL",
      "selected_geometric_solution": {
        "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-CAST-IN-CHANNEL",
        "classification": "illustrative_value",
        "placed_offset_mm": [2, -1, 112],
        "panel_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 300, "height": 220, "depth": 90 },
        "substrate_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 450, "height": 180, "depth": 75 },
        "panel_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "substrate_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "available_access_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [1000, 350, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 1200, "height": 700, "depth": 700 }
        },
        "observed_obstructions": [
          {
            "observation_id": "OBS-CONCRETE-VALID-001",
            "origin_mm": [2500, 450, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 100, "height": 100, "depth": 100 },
            "description": "Simulated service obstruction outside the connector access zone."
          }
        ],
        "observed_unapproved_penetrations": [
          {
            "observation_id": "PEN-UNAPPROVED-CONCRETE-001",
            "origin_mm": [2400, 50, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 50, "height": 50, "depth": 50 },
            "description": "Simulated unrelated penetration outside the candidate keep-out zone."
          }
        ],
        "access_zone_clear": true,
        "keep_out_zones_clear": true,
        "fit_summary": "The bracket uses 2 mm horizontal, -1 mm vertical, and 2 mm outward adjustment from nominal. Both footprints remain inside their attachment zones, the 500 x 350 x 400 mm access zone is clear, and the protected slab-edge zone has no conflicting penetration in this simulated placement.",
        "geometry_evidence_refs": ["EV-GEOMETRY-CONCRETE-VALID"]
      },
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-CAST-IN-CHANNEL",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "pass",
          "ranking_eligible": true,
          "score": 78.5,
          "rank": 1,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HARD-GATE", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-RANKING"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-POST-INSTALLED",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "pass",
          "ranking_eligible": true,
          "score": 76.5,
          "rank": 2,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HARD-GATE", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-RANKING"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-VALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Send the selected candidate and alternate, exact project inputs, evidence, fire and seismic prerequisites, and limitations to qualified facade, structural, and concrete reviewers.",
      "plain_language_summary": "The current CTO/CIS mating checks and geometry screens pass. Both simulated concrete connector candidates remain eligible, and the cast-in channel ranks first. No engineering domain ran."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "invalid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-CAST-IN-CHANNEL",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-POST-INSTALLED",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INVALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Correct panel-to-edge placement and attachment-zone geometry, then revise the proposed anchor location and project demand before re-running candidate screening.",
      "plain_language_summary": "CIS identity and declared sides match, but frame gap, normal alignment, attachment-zone overlap, anchor edge distance, and simulated demand screens fail. Nothing is ranked."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "indeterminate",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "indeterminate", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-CAST-IN-CHANNEL",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CONCRETE-POST-INSTALLED",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CONCRETE-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Provide a cast-in or as-built record, concrete properties, reinforcement scan, cracked-condition declaration, project demands, and material, fire, and seismic review requests.",
      "plain_language_summary": "Interface and geometry checks ran and passed. Candidate applicability ran but cannot decide because material and demand facts are missing. Hard gates, ranking, and engineering review did not run."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CLT-VALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CLT-VALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "valid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-SCREW-ANGLE",
      "selected_geometric_solution": {
        "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-SCREW-ANGLE",
        "classification": "illustrative_value",
        "placed_offset_mm": [1, 2, 118],
        "panel_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 320, "height": 220, "depth": 95 },
        "substrate_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 420, "height": 260, "depth": 160 },
        "panel_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "substrate_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "available_access_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [1000, 350, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 1200, "height": 700, "depth": 700 }
        },
        "observed_obstructions": [
          {
            "observation_id": "OBS-CLT-VALID-001",
            "origin_mm": [2500, 450, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 100, "height": 100, "depth": 100 },
            "description": "Simulated service obstruction outside the connector access zone."
          }
        ],
        "observed_unapproved_penetrations": [
          {
            "observation_id": "PEN-UNAPPROVED-CLT-001",
            "origin_mm": [2400, 50, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 50, "height": 50, "depth": 50 },
            "description": "Simulated unrelated penetration outside the candidate keep-out zone."
          }
        ],
        "access_zone_clear": true,
        "keep_out_zones_clear": true,
        "fit_summary": "The angle uses 1 mm horizontal, 2 mm vertical, and 3 mm outward adjustment from nominal. The 420 x 260 x 160 mm CLT-side footprint and simulated screw-group volume remain within the declared connection zone, and the 520 x 380 x 420 mm access zone is clear.",
        "geometry_evidence_refs": ["EV-GEOMETRY-CLT-VALID"]
      },
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-SCREW-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "pass",
          "ranking_eligible": true,
          "score": 80.25,
          "rank": 1,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HARD-GATE", "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-RANKING"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-CONCEALED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "pass",
          "ranking_eligible": true,
          "score": 67.5,
          "rank": 2,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HARD-GATE", "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-RANKING"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-VALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Send the selected candidate and alternate, CLT product identity, axis, edge condition, fastener geometry, fabrication model, moisture class, fire strategy, seismic basis, and project demands to qualified reviewers.",
      "plain_language_summary": "The interface and geometry screens pass. Both simulated CLT candidates are eligible, and the screw-angle candidate ranks first. Timber, fire, seismic, and facade engineering did not run."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CLT-INVALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CLT-INVALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "invalid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-SCREW-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-CONCEALED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INVALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Correct placement and attachment-zone geometry, then revise fastener edge distance, embedment, and project demand before re-running the screen.",
      "plain_language_summary": "The CIS declarations match, but geometry and both simulated timber candidate screens fail. A score is not produced."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "indeterminate",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "indeterminate", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-SCREW-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-CLT-CONCEALED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-CLT-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Provide the CLT layup, major axis, edge condition, fabrication model, moisture class, fastener embedment, demands, and material, fire, and seismic review requests.",
      "plain_language_summary": "Geometry passes, but the timber applicability check cannot decide from the available facts. Later gates, ranking, and qualified review did not run."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-STEEL-VALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-STEEL-VALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "valid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-BOLTED-SHELF-ANGLE",
      "selected_geometric_solution": {
        "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-BOLTED-SHELF-ANGLE",
        "classification": "illustrative_value",
        "placed_offset_mm": [-2, 1, 108],
        "panel_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 330, "height": 230, "depth": 100 },
        "substrate_side_footprint_mm": { "width": 400, "height": 260, "depth": 90 },
        "panel_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "substrate_attachment_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [0, 0, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 3000, "height": 400, "depth": 250 }
        },
        "available_access_zone": {
          "origin_mm": [1000, 350, 0],
          "dimensions_mm": { "width": 1200, "height": 700, "depth": 700 }
        },
        "observed_obstructions": [
          {
            "observation_id": "OBS-STEEL-VALID-001",
            "origin_mm": [2500, 450, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 100, "height": 100, "depth": 100 },
            "description": "Simulated service obstruction outside the connector access zone."
          }
        ],
        "observed_unapproved_penetrations": [
          {
            "observation_id": "PEN-UNAPPROVED-STEEL-001",
            "origin_mm": [2400, 50, 0],
            "dimensions_mm": { "width": 50, "height": 50, "depth": 50 },
            "description": "Simulated unrelated penetration outside the candidate keep-out zone."
          }
        ],
        "access_zone_clear": true,
        "keep_out_zones_clear": true,
        "fit_summary": "The shelf angle uses -2 mm horizontal, 1 mm vertical, and 3 mm outward adjustment from nominal. Both footprints fit inside their declared zones, the coordinated bolt-hole envelope remains clear of the member edge, and the 560 x 400 x 450 mm bolting access zone is unobstructed in the simulated placement.",
        "geometry_evidence_refs": ["EV-GEOMETRY-STEEL-VALID"]
      },
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-BOLTED-SHELF-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "pass",
          "ranking_eligible": true,
          "score": 78.5,
          "rank": 1,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HARD-GATE", "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-RANKING"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-WELDED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "not_applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-VALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Send the selected bolted candidate, member and hole data, field-welding prohibition, project demands, fire strategy, and seismic basis to qualified reviewers.",
      "plain_language_summary": "The interface and geometry screens pass. The bolted shelf angle is eligible and ranks first. The welded plate is not applicable because field welding is prohibited in this scenario. Steel, bolt, fire, seismic, and facade engineering did not run."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-STEEL-INVALID",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "invalid",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "fail", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-BOLTED-SHELF-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-WELDED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "applicable",
          "hard_gate_status": "fail",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INVALID-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Correct placement and attachment-zone geometry, revise hole or plate clearances and project demands, then re-run before choosing a fabrication path.",
      "plain_language_summary": "The CIS declarations match, but geometry and both simulated steel candidate screens fail. No ranking or engineering review ran."
    },
    {
      "evaluation_id": "EVAL-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE",
      "scenario_id": "CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE",
      "classification": "illustrative_value",
      "evaluator_ref": "cwse-reference-evaluator@0.1.0",
      "overall_outcome": "indeterminate",
      "engineering_approval": false,
      "selected_candidate_id": null,
      "selected_geometric_solution": null,
      "stage_results": [
        { "stage_id": "schema_integrity", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA"] },
        { "stage_id": "interface_compatibility", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE"] },
        { "stage_id": "geometry_mating", "status": "pass", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY"] },
        { "stage_id": "candidate_applicability", "status": "indeterminate", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY"] },
        { "stage_id": "deterministic_hard_gate", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"] },
        { "stage_id": "scored_ranking", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-RANKING"] },
        { "stage_id": "qualified_handoff", "status": "not_evaluated", "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"] }
      ],
      "candidate_results": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-BOLTED-SHELF-ANGLE",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "CONN-STEEL-WELDED-PLATE",
          "applicability_status": "indeterminate",
          "hard_gate_status": "not_evaluated",
          "ranking_eligible": false,
          "score": null,
          "rank": null,
          "receipt_refs": ["R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY", "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE"]
        }
      ],
      "receipt_refs": [
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-SCHEMA",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-INTERFACE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-GEOMETRY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-APPLICABILITY",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HARD-GATE",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-RANKING",
        "R-CWSE-STEEL-INDETERMINATE-HANDOFF"
      ],
      "next_action": "Provide steel grade and thickness, bolting access, coordinated holes, drilling authority, welding and repair records, demands, and material, fire, and seismic review requests.",
      "plain_language_summary": "Geometry passes, but the steel applicability check cannot decide from the available material and fabrication facts. Later gates, ranking, and engineering review did not run."
    }
  ]
}